ineptshieldmaid: Language is my playground (Narnia - Queen Lucy)
[personal profile] ineptshieldmaid posting in [community profile] alwaysaqueen
This post and the comments to it contain spoilers. SPOILERS, I repeat!

1. Lucy was awesome. Spectacular, amazing, wonderful, etc. She looked brilliant in tunic and trousers; I loved how determined she was, that little snarl every time someone got the better of her...
1b. But did they really have to play up the bit about not being as beautiful as Susan? *grumbles* For one thing, there is a whole damn lot more to Susan than just being pretty... And seriously, Lucy's already grown up once, she'd have to *know* that she isn't going to end up looking like Susan, and... *sigh* I know it was in the book, but they wrote out plenty of other things, why keep this one?
1c. HAving said that, I like that we resolved this on the "when you grow up you should be just like you" note. Not exactly a message that CS Lewis seemed to have his head around (everyone is secretly a noble warrior, unless they're a filthy traitor or a lipstick-wearing tart!); I like that the movie!verse isn't telling us that Lucy is the only kind of woman to be, or even the best kind of woman to be.

2. Holy crap they passed the Bechdel test. At least three times - and without majorly screwing up the plot. I am kinda disappointed that Gail didn't get to do much aside from sit around - couldn't we have seen her, I dunno, scrubbing decks? Helping out around ship somehow? But it was lovely to see Lucy being protective, d'awww. Turns out Gail was mostly there for the plot arc mentioned at 1c, which was flimsy... but hey, a plot arc entirely involving women (and one metaphysical lion) is better than no plot arc involving women. And WAY better than working out Lucy's self-image crisis in relation to, say, Caspian.

3. OK, so Caspian's wife-to-be can apparently change her shape at will. Bet *that* makes for an interesting royal sex life.
3b. What, you mean I'm supposed to have something meaningful to say about her? OK, I was entertained by how much she was obviously influenced, in terms of cinematic design, by Yvaine from Stardust (which is recursive, since I would imagine that Yvaine, as character, was at least in part influenced by Ramandu's daughter...).
ED: 3c. In the course of figuring out how to spell Lilliandil, I discovered that the actress, Laura Brent, is Australian! *fistbump of national pride*

4. I am intrigued by the fact that they had Susan writing to Edmund and Lucy, speaking of Narnia. I guess if they never film the Last Battle (which for the love of all that's sensible I hope they do not) they never have to have Susan becoming 'no longer a friend of Narnia'. Hmm.

5. They left the door wide open for the Silver Chair to pick up! Here's hoping they find someone awesome to play Jill Pole :D:D:D:D

COME AND TELL ME WHAT YOU THINK. When it comes out in your country, anyway. *smug Australian is smug*

6. Speaking of awesome women, I LOVED their use of the Pauline Baynes images at the end - they stood out *wonderfully* in 3D, and it was just so nice to see that as a tribute to her work. :D

(no subject)

Date: 2010-12-05 03:48 am (UTC)
clare_dragonfly: woman with green feathery wings, text: stories last longer: but only by becoming only stories (Witchy: lightning)
From: [personal profile] clare_dragonfly
It's not out in my country yet, but my mom got passes to a screening ;) And they had a trivia contest and I won a prize! A tote bag and a T-shirt with the logo of a local radio station, and two Dawn Treader posters! I could have won seven times over, I'm sure (the other three trivia questions were on the movies specifically, not the books) but the guy only called on me once...

Anyway, on to the actual movie. Though I don't think I have much to say that you didn't. Similar thoughts on Gail, similar thoughts on Susan. I do think the Dufflepuds got the short stick and that ended up with weird treatment of women--"This one's a girl. This one too! She reads!" but they never explained why they wanted women, and there were no Dufflepud women in evidence, though they (or at least a Dufflepud girl) clearly existed in the book.

I thought it was very interesting that they chose to have Lilliandil show up and not Ramandu himself, though his name still got in there. I was a little sad not to see Ramandu, but I can see why they made that decision: she's important (if not around at all) in The Silver Chair, and Ramandu doesn't show up again.

Basically, I was happy with the movie except for the tacked-on mist plot. I can sort of see why they added it, but it didn't seem to contribute much and it didn't have a satisfying resolution. And even my friend who didn't remember the book thought the mist seemed tacked on.

(no subject)

Date: 2010-12-06 08:48 pm (UTC)
be_themoon: I want a better world. By me. (Default)
From: [personal profile] be_themoon
I am so exciiiiiited for this movie!


alwaysaqueen: Lucy: always a queen (Default)
Once a Queen in Narnia...

April 2011


Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Page generated Sep. 24th, 2017 01:13 am
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios